Showing posts with label Public Speaking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Public Speaking. Show all posts

Thursday, September 25, 2025

Lavatory Oratory, Yet Again


Back in March of this year I wrote a post titled Lavatory Oratory, in which I bemoaned the rambling and nonsensical, yet perversely effective speaking style of the Orange Airhorn. On Tuesday of this week, he gassed onto the world stage with a speech to the UN General Assembly described by historian Heather Cox Richardson as "delusional and offensive," and causing one unnamed foreign diplomat to comment in a text to Washington Post reporter Ishaan Tharoor, “This man is stark raving mad. Do Americans not see how embarrassing this is?"

Some of us do.

I have never been so ashamed to be an American. Not so much because of the ludicrous buffoonery of Der Furor (which is bad enough), but because so many of my fellow Americans - knowing what he is - elected him twice, and are either standing by silently or happily cheering as he runs roughshod over the law, the Constitution, and simple human decency. I'm ashamed because no one in a position of authority and responsibility is standing up and telling this man to his face that he needs to go. As if he hadn't provided enough excuses for the invocation of the 25th Amendment already, his shocking performance in front of the assembled leaders of the world puts the cherry on the miserable sundae of his misrule. 

Cartoon by Patrick Chappette, 2017 - as appropriate as ever.

A great nation once represented by such brilliant and honorable public servants and orators as George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, and Franklin Roosevelt is now represented by a malevolent, incoherent, gaseous oaf unfit to hold any office of responsibility, much less the presidency.

We deserve better. Hopefully, if we survive to 2028, enough of us will have rediscovered reason and responsibility to elect it.

Have a good day. More thoughts tomorrow, when we greet the last collection of Great Moments in Editing and Signage for the month.

Bilbo

Thursday, March 06, 2025

Lavatory Oratory


This past Tuesday evening the Orange Airhorn delivered the first speech of his second reign to a joint session of Congress. It was the longest such speech in modern history (clocking in at almost 100 minutes*), and the sort of speech we've come to expect from him: short on facts and long on self-congratulation, distortions, insults, and threats. I didn't bother watching because I assumed he wouldn't say anything worth listening to, plus I can't stand the sound of his voice and the style of his delivery.

He's a terrible public speaker, but - perversely - he's a very effective one. 

Back in January I wrote a post about The Decline of Public Speaking, in which I compared the oratorical style of Der Furor with that of Adolf Hitler. I noted at the time that 

Whatever else he may have been, Adolf Hitler was a spellbinding orator with a brilliant ability to match his preparation and delivery to the audience. Der Furor, on the other hand, is a terrible speaker - his speeches are not the focused, compelling addresses of an educated statesman speaking with the gravitas of office, but stream-of-consciousness monologs, full of bizarre claims, childish insults, gross misrepresentations, rambling non sequiturs, and self-indulgent blather.

All of that's true, but I realized after discussing it with my wife and my daughter that it really doesn't matter. Der Furor isn't crafting memorable oratory for the ages - he's talking straight to the audience he wants to reach in the words and style they want to hear. As I wrote in that earlier post, his delivery

appeals to less-educated audiences with short attention spans, who want to be entertained rather than informed or persuaded.

He's practicing what I call lavatory oratory.

People who love this president don't want to hear grand plans and lofty visions for the future ... they want to have their biases and their suspicions confirmed, to know that the radical left lunatics responsible for all their ills are finally getting their comeuppance. They're listening for the confirmation that their favorite president is leading them into a future so fantastic that it can be expressed only in the language of superlatives, never mind that there's no evidence of an actual plan to get there. He says it, so it must be true.


This weekend, I'll be judging a high school debate competition in which earnest young people attempt to sway my opinion their way. I'll judge them on how well they weave facts into compelling arguments, deliver them with conviction, and successfully rebut the facts and arguments presented by their opponents. The winner will win on the basis of facts well presented and arguments well defended; they will most certainly not win if they mimic the lavatory oratory of their president.

Have a good day. Expect better of your elected leaders.

More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

* The previous record holder was President Bill Clinton, who spoke for just shy of 89 minutes in 2000.

Monday, January 13, 2025

The Decline of Public Speaking


Unlike many people, I enjoy public speaking. I've been a member of several Toastmasters International clubs over the years, and have won prizes in public speaking contests. I've spoken in front of audiences as small as two and as large as more than a thousand, and often serve as a master of ceremonies for various events. I also judge high school speech and debate competitions (having been originally volunteered by my granddaughter, whose debate team needs to provide judges to participate in competitions). And while I enjoy public speaking, I also enjoy listening to a well-crafted, well-delivered speech that combines good preparation with skill of delivery appropriate to the subject and the occasion.

I've been thinking a lot about public speaking lately, because there isn't much of it that's very good any more. As Hansell Duckett once noted, "What this country needs is more free speech worth listening to."

I'm currently reading "Hitler: Ascent (1889-1939)," book one of a two-volume biography by Volker Ullrich. It's common nowadays to compare Der Furor to Hitler, and - as this detailed, thoroughly researched, and very readable biography demonstrates - comparisons of their personalities, methods, actions, and general behavior are very much on the mark ... with one major exception, as my friend Trang pointed out in her comment on my Facebook post recommending the book:

"There's one big difference between Hitler with his oratory skills and der Furor whose lack of eloquence is astounding. The man can't ever seem to utter a complete sentence that makes sense."

Trang's comment was spot-on. Whatever else he may have been, Adolf Hitler was a spellbinding orator with a brilliant ability to match his preparation and delivery to the audience. Der Furor, on the other hand, is a terrible speaker - his speeches are not the focused, compelling addresses of an educated statesman speaking with the gravitas of office, but stream-of-consciousness monologs, full of bizarre claims, childish insults, gross misrepresentations, rambling non sequiturs, and self-indulgent blather. It's a style he likes to call "the weave" as if it were some profoundly brilliant oratorical technique only he can master, and one that appeals to less-educated audiences with short attention spans, who want to be entertained rather than informed or persuaded. If Der Furor were to compete in any high school speech contest I was judging, I'd have to seek the organizer's permission to give him a low enough score.

Now consider last week's funeral of former president Jimmy Carter. Speaker after speaker gave heartfelt, excellent eulogies ... not an easy type of presentation to write or deliver. Each eulogy brilliantly mixed love, respect, and humor in memory of a man remembered less as a great president than as a decent and humble human being. I cannot imagine that Der Furor could have risen to the challenge of the moment, and I cringe* to think of what will happen if we need to have a state funeral while he is in office. In July of 2022 I wrote a blog post reimagining the Gettysburg Address as Der Furor would have  delivered it that can serve as an example of the sort of soaring presidential rhetoric we can expect again in the next four years.

A few years ago, drama and theater critic Peter Marks wrote, “... if you’ve ever listened to some of the desultory rhetoric from the well of the Senate, you know that American politics has not exactly built an assembly line of Ciceros.” We live in a time when attention spans are short and good public speaking is insufficiently valued. It's a time when crude tweets that sow hatred and division carry more weight than soaring oration that inspires and motivates. 

And that's sad.

Have a good day, and support your local school's speech and debate clubs.

More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

* Yes, I know it's on the banished words list for this year, but it just seemed right.

Monday, March 11, 2024

Talking the Talk


Last Thursday evening President Biden delivered the traditional and Constitutionally-mandated* State of the Union speech. As has become sadly normal in these times, the speech was less a dignified overview of the current state and future direction of the nation than a feistily-delivered and angrily-received laundry list that checked all the expected boxes (reproductive rights, voting rights, Ukraine, Gaza, immigration, presidential vitality, etc).


Simply put, the State of the Union speech (or "SOTU," for short) is what has replaced inspirational, thought-provoking oration. As drama and theater critic Peter Marks said a few years ago, 

“... if you’ve ever listened to some of the desultory rhetoric from the well of the Senate, you know that American politics has not exactly built an assembly line of Ciceros.”

As you may recall, I love public speaking and think I'm pretty good at it**. I enjoy preparing and delivering an entertaining and thought-provoking speech, and I especially enjoy listening to one. Unfortunately, nowadays there aren't a lot of speeches worth listening to.

We've come a long way from Lincoln's Gettysburg Address, Franklin Roosevelt's stirring "Four Freedoms" and first inaugural ("Nothing to fear but fear itself") speeches, and John F. Kennedy's "Ask not what your country can do for you" inaugural address.

What do we have now?

We have angry, meaningless word salads from Der Furor that are nevertheless cheered by those unused to thinking in terms of the nation, the world, and the common good. Or, in fact, to thinking at all.


We have a State of the Union address delivered in a forcefully belligerent tone in an attempt to combat the persistent image of a president diminished by age ... an address that was memorable more for its delivery than for its content.

This is sad.

I serve from time to time as a judge for local high school debates, and enjoy the chance to see young people do the difficult work of organizing and presenting ideas with the aim of changing minds. Unfortunately, while they are almost always superb at amassing facts and assembling arguments, they tend to be far less skilled at actually delivering those arguments in a way that will sway the opinions of their audience. Emphasis is placed more on the rapid-fire delivery of as many facts and arguments as can be jammed into a given period of time (anywhere from two to seven minutes in most debates I judge) ... with the result that the listener feels like the exhausted survivor of an oratorical tsunami. 

I firmly believe that two of the most vital skills we can teach our children are to speak and write clearly ... and yet these are the skills lost on a population unable or unwilling to read complex arguments, write cogent and thoughtful letters, and deliver or listen to thought-provoking, challenging speeches.

We don't need the lost assembly line of Ciceros bemoaned by Peter Marks, but we do need a population that can read, listen, speak, and think ... the very population that, sadly, can be swayed by the useless blatherings of empty windbags.

Have a good day, and listen critically to the speeches you hear during this election year. Learn to separate the wheat of rational ideas and policies from the chaff of unfocused anger and retribution. Vote for content - not for noise.

More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

* Article 2, Section 3, Clause 1.

** Pats self on back.