Showing posts with label Religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Religion. Show all posts

Monday, August 04, 2025

Permission to Proselytize


Back when I was a retired officer working as a contractor on the Air Staff at the Pentagon, I sat next to another contractor (from a different company) who was constantly pushing his religious beliefs on me. I repeatedly told him his comments were not welcome or appreciated, but his only response was to tell me that, although I was most likely going to hell for all eternity, he would "pray for me."


This guy was a self-important nuisance, utterly convinced that his religious beliefs were the only ones that were true and correct and that it was his job to convince me of the error of my ways. But that's all he was ... a nuisance. Today, if you are a federal employee who has the misfortune of working with a person like that who happens to be your supervisor, you could be in trouble not just in some imagined future, but in the intolerant present. 

One of what used to be the bedrock principles of the United States was the official separation of church and state in governance. The Founders had lived through the European wars of religion and seen the results of the oppression of one religion by another, and wrote their concerns into Article VI of the Constitution:

"no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States"

and as the first words of the First Amendment:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof"

All of that changed with the guidance memorandum issued by the Office of Personnel Management on July 28th, titled "Protecting Religious Expression in the Federal Workplace." Under the guise of protecting Americans' First Amendment rights of religious belief and expression, Der Furor's administration has pandered to the "religious" right* by permitting ... and all but encouraging ... the intrusion of religious proselytization into federal offices.

The OPM memo attempts to sidestep the issue of religious beliefs affecting superior/subordinate relations when it says that

"The constitutional rights of supervisors to engage in such conversations [regarding religious topics] should not be distinguished from non-supervisory employees by the nature of their supervisory roles. However, unwillingness to engage in such conversations may not be the basis of workplace discipline." 

Riddle me this, Batman: do you really believe that a supervisor who believes her religious beliefs and attitudes are superior to those of her subordinate - to the extent that she tries to convince that subordinate change his beliefs to match her own - can be a fair and otherwise nonjudgmental boss?

Appendix 1 of the OPM memo gives examples of "permissible religious expression in the workplace." Here are two examples:

"During a break, an employee may engage another in polite discussion of why his faith is correct and why the non-adherent should re-think his religious beliefs. However, if the nonadherent requests such attempts to stop, the employee should honor the request." And if the first employee declines to honor the request, what then? The overall tone of the memo suggests that the freedom of a religious employee to "engage" with others - even when that engagement is unwanted - takes precedence over a "nonadherent" employee's freedom to avoid such engagement. 

"A park ranger leading a tour through a national park may join her tour group in prayer." This implies that if a tour group should spontaneously break out in prayer, the ranger is free to join in. Can the ranger stop the tour herself and ask the group to join in prayer? Under this administration, almost certainly.

The First Amendment specifies two things: that the government may not establish a state religion, and that citizens are free to worship as they see fit. While it is arguably true that various forms of Christianity have predominated the religious character of the country, this is not because the federal government has "established" them, but because the majority of the citizens have historically belonged to Christian forms of worship. One wonders whether the drafter of the OPM memo would react the same way to complaints about Jews, Muslims, Zoroastrians, Buddhists, or Satanists, rather than Christians, proselytizing in federal workplaces. 

I think I know the answer.

Have a good day. Observe the tenets of your religion, and respect the right of others to observe their own. Or not.

More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

* I use the term "religious" advisedly, because the language and actions of many self-described devout Christians in this country bear only the most tenuous relationship to the actual teachings of Christ.

Thursday, March 20, 2025

American Christianity, 2025


You may have seen the news report about the study from the Pew Research Center showing that the decline of "Christianity" in the US has slowed and may have stabilized. The study data indicate that, after many years of steady decline, the share of Americans who identify as "Christian" shows signs of leveling off – at least temporarily – at slightly above six-in-ten.

I put the words "Christianity" and "Christian" in quotes because today's American version of the religion formerly known as Christianity has little or nothing to do with the teachings of Christ, and many of its American followers who style themselves as "Christians" are the least Christ-like people on Earth. 

I was born and baptized as a Byzantine Rite Catholic many years ago, but grew up in a mainly Roman Catholic environment. I went to a parochial elementary school, attended Sunday School once I entered high school, and remained a regular church-going fellow until a year or two after graduation from college. Over the years, having graduated from a public high school and college, served in the military, and traveled widely in other cultures, I came to understand that there is a wide range of religious beliefs, most of which tend to insist on their primacy, and that each one claims to have the "right" beliefs and the "true" connection to God. 


The worst, in my opinion*, are the noisy and intolerant so-called "Christians" of the American right. These are the people who, while noisily announcing their devotion at every opportunity, vote for people like Der Furor who are the very antithesis of Christian love and charity. They are the people who donate money they can't afford to rich televangelists who live in houses and follow a lifestyle their followers could never afford. In Congress, they are the people who pray ostentatiously while following the most un-Christian of party ideologies, happily slashing programs that help the less fortunate while blindly following a man so awful that one has to wonder why he hasn't been struck by a bolt of lightning from an exasperated Creator.


I've often heard people remark about how "deeply religious" so many Americans are. Of course, the leaders of the Spanish Inquisition were also deeply religious, as were the good citizens of Salem who burned the witches.

I think I'll pass, thank you.

Have a good day, and please keep your religion to yourself if you're one of those people who claims exclusive knowledge of the Only Way.

More thoughts tomorrow, when we try to single out the next winner of the tinfoil and toilet paper crown - the Left-Cheek Ass Clown for March. See you then.

Bilbo

* Other than the most violently extreme Islamic fundamentalists.

Tuesday, October 29, 2024

Israel/Gaza/Lebanon and an American Election


There are a lot of things grinding my gears about this year's election, but the thing that - at least today - is at the top of the list is the effect of Middle Eastern war and politics on our choice of president.

You may recall my basic position on the situation of Israel, the Palestinians, and the rest of the Middle East, which I spelled out in my post almost a year ago titled, "A Plague on Both Your Houses." As far as I'm concerned, the best solution to the problem would be to build a wall a thousand feet high around the entire region, fill it to the top with sand, and start over.

The problem with the Middle East isn't the undying hatred and the endless cycle of attack-respond-attack-respond. The problem is that it's become the rest of the world's problem. I personally don't care if the Jews and Arabs of the Middle East make a national sport of killing each other. What I do care about is that those hatreds are threatening to destroy the United States.

Across the nation, Arab Americans enraged by the Biden Administration's support for Israel are threatening to sit out the election or - worse - vote for Der Furor in the comical belief that he actually cares about them and would put more pressure on Israel to end the wars in Gaza, the West Bank, and Lebanon. Likewise, Jewish Americans enraged by a Biden Administration they feel is insufficiently supportive of Israel threaten either to sit out the election or to accept the comical belief that Der Furor actually cares about them and would go "all-in" against Israel's enemies*.

I am neither Jewish nor Arab/Muslim, but I have close friends in each camp. They are all sincere in their beliefs and their anger, and those beliefs and anger - which have echoed down the years at least since the well-intentioned but ultimately deadly Balfour Declaration of 1917 - have only grown more intense with each new death. And now all that accumulated hatred and religious bitterness threatens to upend our election here at home and return to power an angry authoritarian driven by petty jealousy, animosity toward his enemies real and perceived, and a disdain for democratic norms and common decency.

There are no ... no ... clean hands in the ongoing horror of the Middle East. I understand the legitimate fears and desires of both sides, but decry the rigidly zero-sum unwillingness of each to seek a peaceful resolution. Any such resolution will leave each side unsatisfied, but in the words of the "Game of Thrones" character Tyrion Lannister, “No one is very happy, which means it’s a good compromise, I suppose.” 

Do not allow your vote to be decided by undying hatreds from the other side of the world. No matter how sincerely you may want the carnage to end, what's important is that the ones actually fighting want it ... and, so far, they don't.

Have a good day and make sure you vote on the basis of what's good for the United States, not the goals of bitter enemies a world away.

More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

* To the extent that Der Furor admires leaders he perceives as strong and ruthless, he tends to support Israel's Benjamin Netanyahu. And the fact that he receives more financial support from Jewish than from Arab supporters doesn't hurt, either.

Monday, July 29, 2024

God's Satisfaction Questionnaire


A few years ago, I published a post titled "God's Satisfaction Questionnaire." Given the rise of militant and intolerant religious belief in today's America, and the desire of many believers to impose their beliefs on the rest of us, I thought it might be time to update and republish that questionnaire for a new era ...

God's Satisfaction Questionnaire
Please Answer All Questions

God would like to thank you for your belief and patronage. In order to better serve your needs, He* asks that you take a few moments to answer the following questions. Please keep in mind that your responses will be kept completely confidential, and that you need not disclose your name or address unless you prefer a direct visitation in response to comments or suggestions.

* Please note that God is all-powerful and independent of sex or sexual orientation. The pronouns "He," "His," "Him," etc, are used solely for grammatical convenience and are not intended to specify or elevate the position and authority of a particular sex.

1. How did you find out about God?
__ Bible
__ Quran
__ Torah
__ Rig Veda
__ Book of Mormon
__ Other Book (specify): _____________
__ Divine Inspiration
__ Burning Shrubbery
__ Near Death Experience
__ Newspaper
__ Television
__ Word of Mouth
__ Tabloid
__ Weird Guy Screaming on Street Corner
__ Other (specify): _____________

2. Which model God did you acquire?
__ God (generic)
__ Yahweh
__ Jehova
__ Allah
__ Father, Son and Holy Ghost Triplet
__ Jesus
__ Great Spirit
__ Satan
__ Other (specify): _______________

3. Did you receive your God undamaged, with no missing attributes?
__ Yes __ No (If no, please describe any problems you initially encountered. Use a separate sheet of paper if necessary)

4. What factors were relevant in your decision to acquire a God? Please check all that apply.
__ Indoctrinated by Parents
__ Wanted to Piss off Parents
__ Indoctrinated by Society
__ Needed a Reason to Live
__ Needed Focus in Who to Despise
__ Need to Feel Morally Superior to Everyone Else
__ Desperate Need for Certainty
__ Imaginary Friend Grew Up
__ Hate to Think for Myself
__ Needed a Day Away from Work
__ Fear of Death
__ Wanted to Meet Girls/Boys
__ Like Organ Music
__ My Shrubbery Caught Fire and Told Me to Do It

5. Have you ever worshipped a God before?
__ Yes __ No

6. If you answered Yes to Question 5, which God did you worship? Please check all that apply.
__ Odin
__ Zeus
__ Apollo
__ Ra
__ The Great Spirit
__ The Great Pumpkin
__ The Sun
__ The Moon
__ The Bomb
__ Cthulhu
__ The Almighty Dollar
__ Donald Trump
__ Other: ________________

6. Are you currently using any other source of inspiration in addition to God? Please check all that apply.
__ None
__ Tarot
__ Lottery
__ Astrology
__ Television
__ Fortune Cookies
__ Psychic Friends Network
__ Dianetics/Scientology
__ Palmistry
__ Self-Help Books
__ Sex, Drugs and Rock and Roll
__ Biorythms
__ Tea Leaves
__ ESP
__ Chanting Mantras
__ Televangelist/Megachurch Pastor (specify which one)
__ Crystals
__ Human Sacrifice
__ Pyramids
__ Wandering Around a Desert
__ Burning Shrubbery
__ Cash/Investments
__ Other: _______________

7. God employs a limited degree of Divine Intervention to preserve the balanced level of felt presence and blind faith. Which would you prefer (circle one)?
a. More Divine Intervention
b. Less Divine Intervention
c. Current level of Divine Intervention is just right

8. God also attempts to maintain a balanced level of disasters and miracles. Please rate on a scale of 1 - 5 his handling of the following (1=unsatisfactory, 5=excellent):
a. Disasters:
Flood 1 2 3 4 5
Pestilence 1 2 3 4 5
War 1 2 3 4 5
Famine 1 2 3 4 5
Plague 1 2 3 4 5
Earthquake 1 2 3 4 5
al Qaeda (or Similar Organization) 1 2 3 4 5
Spam 1 2 3 4 5
Congress 1 2 3 4 5
MAGA 1 2 3 4 5
American-style Political Campaign 1 2 3 4 5
Internet Outage 1 2 3 4 5

b. Miracles:
Rescues 1 2 3 4 5
Water Changing to Wine 1 2 3 4 5
Spontaneous Remissions 1 2 3 4 5
Talking, Flaming Shrubbery 1 2 3 4 5
Stars Hovering over Towns 1 2 3 4 5
Crying Statues 1 2 3 4 5
Congress Actually Doing Something Useful 1 2 3 4 5
Walking on Water 1 2 3 4 5
Donald Trump Delivering Coherent Speech 1 2 3 4 5
Consumer Devices Setting Their Own Clocks 1 2 3 4 5

9. Do you have any additional comments or suggestions for improving the quality of God's services? (Attach an additional sheet if necessary):

Thank you for your time in completing this valuable survey to help God improve His service to you.


Have a good day. More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

Monday, February 26, 2024

Black-Letter Law


In reviewing the story of the Alabama supreme court decision on the status of embryos being stored for in-vitro fertilization (IFV) treatments, I learned an interesting new term: "black-letter law" (also known as "hornbook law"), defined as 

"... standard rules that are generally known and free from doubt. The black letter law on any subject consists of the principles so fundamental in that subject and contained so frequently in hundreds of years of common law that challenging them would be extremely difficult."

This appears to be related to the legal principle, recently shredded by the U.S. Supreme Court, of "stare decisis" ("settled law"), which states that

"... courts will adhere to precedent in making their decisions."

Black-letter law may not be as black*, nor stare decisis as settled as we think, for the Supreme Court has also ruled that 

"... stare decisis is not an “inexorable command.” When prior decisions are “unworkable or are badly reasoned,” then the Supreme Court may not follow precedent, and this is “particularly true in constitutional cases.”

But who decides whether a prior decision is "unworkable or badly reasoned," and on what basis do they make the decision? 

The waiver of stare decisis has allowed the righteous overturning of disastrous decisions like Plessy v. Ferguson, which sanctioned racial segregation in the United States. Unfortunately, it has also led to more questionable decisions such as the recent Dobbs decision that overturned the protection of abortion rights codified in Roe v. Wade ... the first time** a Supreme Court decision has taken away, rather than granted or reinforced a right. Where one can defensibly argue that Plessy v. Ferguson was "wrongly decided" based on Constitutional guarantees of equal rights (not to mention simple human decency), the decision to overturn Roe v. Wade - like the decision in the Alabama case - seems to have been based primarily on religious arguments of questionable Constitutional validity which replaced factual legal analysis and logic with faith-based theological dogma.

We are approaching a time when "black-letter law" is what the party with political control of the courts decides it is. The current Supreme Court, heavily conservative, is clearly willing to overturn settled law with which it philosophically disagrees, stare decisis be damned. 

Perhaps it is time to stop referring to "black-letter law" and start referring to "gray-letter law." The Scarlet Letter has already been taken, in a different context ... and if the GOP has its way, it may well be back.

Have a good day. More thoughts coming.

Bilbo


* I'm reminded of the wonderfully eerie short story "Absolute Ebony," by Felice Picano, about an artist's search for the ultimate, perfect shade of black ... and what comes with it.

** As far as I know.

Monday, November 27, 2023

A Plague on Both Your Houses


I've been reluctant to weigh in on the subject of the horrible situation in the Middle East because no matter what I say, somebody is going to be enraged and accuse me of ignorantly and unfairly supporting one side or the other. So let me be clear ... in the words of the dying Mercutio in Shakespeare's play "Romeo and Juliet," 

"A plague on both your houses."

Mercutio, you will recall (if you went to school in a time when the classics were part of your education), was what we would today call collateral damage in the blood feud between the warring Capulet and  Montague families. Who was right and who was wrong in the feud didn't matter to poor Mercutio - he was just as pointlessly dead.

And so it is with the endless, bloody feud in the Middle East between Muslims and Jews, Palestinians and Israelis. Each side claims to be in the right, and to have primacy of ownership of what we laughingly call "The Holy Land." Each religion and ethnic group claims exclusive ownership of the land and is willing to murderously enforce its claim against the others.

Religion is at the heart of this terrible and bloody morass, which has been aided and abetted by the political interests of greater and lesser powers within and outside the area ... you may wish to go back and study things like the Balfour Declaration, the League of Nations Mandates, and the 1947 UN partition of Palestine. You may also want to read the masterful nonfiction book A Peace to End All Peace: The Fall of the Ottoman Empire and the Creation of the Modern Middle East, by David Fromkin, for an excellent summary of the great power machinations which laid the political groundwork for our ghastly current situation.

Who is in the right, here? In my opinion, which counts for nothing, nobody.

I have well-educated and politically savvy friends and colleagues, both Jews and Arabs, whose opinions I generally respect, but who go wild with rage against the other side over the current situation in Gaza. Jews point (with obvious good reason) to the horrific slaughter visited on Israeli citizens and others in the brutal Hamas attack on October 6th. Palestinians point (with good reasons of their own) to the occupation of the West Bank and the oppression and dispossession of the Palestinians who live there*. Everybody hates everybody else and everybody blames the other side for the situation. Israelis are motivated to overwhelmingly powerful retaliation against their enemies by the lasting memory of the Holocaust. Palestinians are motivated to violent retaliation against Israelis by the lasting memory of the nakba ("catastrophe") of the creation of Israel and the partition of Palestine. Both Israel and Hamas, in different guises, aim for the ethnic cleansing of the region. 

A plague on both your houses.

Positions in this country have become so polarized and outraged over the situation that even people who should know better insist they will never vote again for President Biden, or will sit out the coming election ... utterly ignoring the obvious social, political, economic, and justice catastrophe - for the nation and the world - of a potential second presidency for Der Furor**. No matter if you are Jew or Muslim, Palestinian or Israeli, Republican or Democrat, if you think things will improve for you if Der Furor returns, you deserve what you get. Sadly, the rest of us will have to suffer along with you.

You can support Israel and still oppose the brutal devastation of Gaza and the deaths of thousands of already-suffering Palestinians. You can support the legitimate aspirations of the Palestinian people and still oppose the blind hatred and violence of Hamas. There are no clean hands, here, and it's good to acknowledge the fact.

In summary,

A plague on both your houses.

I'm through with all of you.

Have a good day. More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

* The part of the Balfour Declaration which reads, "it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine" has long since been conveniently forgotten.

** Or even a lesser GOP demagogue.

Thursday, October 12, 2023

I'm Right, You're Wrong, Screw You


One of the most dispiriting things about living in the year 2023 is the increasing unwillingness of people, governments, political parties, and single-issue partisans to even consider compromising with those with whom they disagree.

In the Middle East, Hamas refuses to negotiate with Israel, causing widespread devastation and death on both sides of the Gaza border, dooming generations on both sides to lives of fear and misery.


American gun zealots refuse to compromise on any measures that might reduce gun violence, viewing the Constitutionally-authorized right to "keep and bear arms" as absolute and inviolable, regardless of the cost in human lives.


Religious fundamentalists refuse to compromise on their complete and total opposition to abortion, regardless of the fact the mother may die or the child be born with defects that would prevent a normal life.

In Congress, individual Senators and Representatives refuse to compromise on their pet issues, preventing meaningful legislation on immigration reform, medical care, education, gun safety, and any number of other issues, and leaving the nation without key military and government leaders at a time of great international peril.

There was a time when we viewed the ability and willingness to compromise as a cornerstone of good government ... Kentucky Representative Henry Clay was actually known as "The Great Compromiser," and his ability to craft compromises helped to quell regionalism and balance states' rights with national interests, helping to hold the nation together in the first half of the 19th century. 


Now, however, the very word compromise is often uttered dripping with scorn, because we have reached a point when many believe that someone who does not share their beliefs is not only wrong, but deliberately and manifestly evil. The state that produced a giant like Henry Clay now gives us legislative midgets  Mitch McConnell, Rand Paul, and James Comer. We have lost the ability to work with others to find common ground in an era of I'm right, you're wrong, screw you.

The opposite problem was illustrated as far back as 1967 in the song "Shades of Gray," written by Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil and performed by The Monkees: 

When the world and I were young
Just yesterday
Live was such a simple game
A child could play
It was easy then to tell right from wrong
Easy then to tell weak from strong
When a man should stand and fight
Or just go along

But today there is no day or night
Today there is no dark or light
Today there is no black or white
Only shades of gray

I remember when the answers seemed so clear
We had never lived with doubt or tasted fear
It was easy then to tell truth from lies
Selling out from compromise
Who to love and who to hate
The foolish from the wise

But today there is no day or night
Today there is no dark or light
Today there is no black or white
Only shades of gray

It was easy then to know what was fair
When to keep and when to share
How much to protect your heart
And how much to care

But today there is no day or night
Today there is no dark or light
Today there is no black or white
Only shades of gray
Only shades of gray

Today, no one paints the world in shades of gray, but in the very starkest black and white that brooks no compromise. I'm right, you're wrong, screw you.

Where is Henry Clay when we need him?

Have a good day, and consider compromise ... the nation needs it and you may discover that things work better with it.

More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

Thursday, August 09, 2018

Economics as Religion


It has occurred to me that modern political economics is a lot like religion, for several reasons:

First, they both require you to take their laws and rules and pronouncements on faith, ignoring evidence to the contrary. Tax cuts will pay for themselves. Cutting taxes on the wealthy helps the poor. Deficits will disappear because the economy will continue to grow at very optimistic rates. Every other country will be happy to renegotiate trade agreements so that the United States will get a better deal at their expense.

Second, they both ask you to make sacrifices and accept pain in the present because the future will be paradise. You can see this as tariffs designed to protect certain industries result in pain for other segments of the economy ... the steel industry may be boosted a bit, but other industries are being hit hard by retaliatory tariffs, and the administration has had to come up with billions of dollars in aid to protect farmers.

Third, they both ask you to believe in miracles, such as Mexico is going to pay for that wall.

If you want to choose a miraculous system in which to believe, GOP economics and religion seem to be equally good options.

Have a good day. More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

Wednesday, October 11, 2017

The Faith Pyramid


Last week in this space, I grumbled about complicated and convoluted modern religiosity, as opposed to the simple "love thy neighbor" dictum of early Christianity. Continuing with that topic, here's an interesting take on the ramifications of religious belief, courtesy of Crispian Jago's* blog, The Reason Stick ...


Since "thoughts and prayers" are the only thing that Congress is able to quickly provide - on a nonpartisan basis - in response to mass murder and natural disasters, it's worth thinking about where those prayers fall on the faith pyramid. Hint ... low.

I have faith in the love of my wife and family, the passage of the seasons, and endless political ass-clownery. Any more, not much else.

Have a good day. More thoughts tomorrow.

Bilbo

* Last June in this space, I featured another of Crispian Jago's offerings, The Periodic Table of Irrational Nonsense. I find his thoughts devastatingly clever, if not always suitable for children.

Wednesday, October 04, 2017

How "Theologically Dense" Is It to "Love Thy Neighbor?"


Those of you, Dear Readers, who have been following my ruminations over the life of this blog, know that I have a fairly conflicted relationship with religion. I was baptized as a Byzantine Rite Catholic, raised in a Roman Catholic tradition, and now self-identify as a Seventh-Day Absenteeist.

Although I no longer adhere to any particular religious tradition, I follow the influence of religious belief on our lives and our politics with great interest, which is why this headline from CNN leaped out at me last week: Conservatives Accuse the Pope of Spreading Heresy. According to the report, more than 60 conservative Catholic scholars and clergy sent a 25-page letter to Pope Francis, accusing him of spreading seven specific heretical beliefs.

The letter is described in the article as being "theologically dense." This means, if you aren't steeped in the minutiae of complex theological argument, you can't follow it.

And this is my problem with most religions as they exist today. Numerous things, actions, and beliefs are "un-Islamic." Various actions and beliefs are "un-Christian." Arguments are "theologically dense." If you don't worship my way, you're a heretic, an apostate, or whatever.

How did we get here? Consider the words of Jesus in chapter 22 of Matthew, verses 35 through 39 ...

35 Then one of them, which was a lawyer*, asked him a question, tempting him, and saying,
36 Master, which is the great commandment in the law?
37 Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind.
38 This is the first and great commandment.
39 And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself.

How did we get from two laws - (1) Love God, and (2) Love your neighbor** - to a 25-page, theologically dense letter accusing Pope Francis of heresy for ... well ... daring to suggest we should love our less-than-perfect neighbors?

Those two great commandments expanded into the Ten Commandments, which eventually begat the Code of Canon Law of the Catholic Church, which is divided into seven books, containing 1,752 individual "canons." Consider also that Islam is wrapped around the theological axle of the Koran, the Hadith, and the millions of interpretations of them that Islamic scholars have generated over the years. And finally, consider that when we describe an argument as Talmudic, it implies that it is "characterized by or making extremely fine distinctions; overly detailed or subtle; hairsplitting."

Love your neighbor. Only three words.

Is that so hard?

Have a good day. More thoughts tomorrow.

Bilbo

* Well, he would be, wouldn't he?

** If you read the seven heretical beliefs with which Pope Francis is being charged, he is essentially charged with upholding the commandment to love one's neighbor. What kind of irreligious bum would do that?

Thursday, December 01, 2016

"Civil Rights" vs "Religious Liberty"


There's a serious issue today that revolves around the accommodation of both religious beliefs and civil rights, and it's not likely to be resolved any time soon. Here's an example ...

A full-page advertisement* appeared on page A7 of the Washington Post on Sunday, October 16th. It was titled "DECLARATION of DEPENDENCE UPON GOD and HIS HOLY BIBLE" (capitalization in the original), and began with these words,

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal and endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights. Since our Creator gave us these rights, we declare that no government has the right to take them away. Among these rights is the right to exercise our Christian beliefs as put forth in God's Holy Bible."

It goes on to specifically oppose abortion**, "... same-sex marriage, polygamy, bestiality, and all other forms of sexual perversion prohibited by Holy Scripture," and closes with this ringing statement:

"Therefore we, the undersigned - not only as Christians but also believing we have the constitutional right as Americans to follow these time honored Christian beliefs - commit to conducting our churches ministries, businesses, and personal lives in accordance with our Christian faith and chose to obey God rather than man."

Translation: those who profess strong, specifically Christian, religious beliefs need not obey the law***.

Here's the dilemma ... citizens of the United States are guaranteed "freedom of religion." But how does unrestricted "freedom of religion" square with community life in a pluralistic society?

My problem with the major monotheistic religions is that they are by nature intolerant of other beliefs. For example, if you are a Christian, you believe absolutely in the literal truth of the Bible, and that unless a person accepts Jesus Christ as his/her lord and savior, that person cannot be saved and is denied entry into heaven. If you are a Muslim, you believe absolutely in the literal truth of the Quran, and that every other form of religious belief is wrong. Neither of these is an especially good recipe for loving your neighbor as yourself†.

I've been concerned about this for a long time, and a while back saw this superb article in the Atlantic Monthly: Even the Government’s Smartest Lawyers Can’t Figure Out Religious Liberty. It's not too long, and is well worth your time to read, particularly if you believe your constitutionally-guaranteed freedom of religion is threatened by laws intended to protect those of whom you disapprove on religious grounds.

In case you don't want to read the whole thing, the main point is this: it is all but impossible in our constitutional republic to both guarantee complete freedom of religious expression and protect the civil rights of minorities - particularly those who are frowned upon by one religion or another. The problem will never be resolved by law - only by the good will of men and women willing to pull their heads out of their rigidly religious backsides.

In case you were wondering why I have chosen not to follow any particular system of religious belief, now you know.

Have a good day. Practice the Golden Rule ... you may find you like it.

Come back tomorrow for the unveiling of our Right-Cheek Ass Clown for December. More thoughts then.

Bilbo

* Paid for by Andrew Wommack Ministries.

** "...unless it is a direct threat to the life of the mother."

*** I'm not sure how this squares with Jesus' admonition in Matthew 22:21 to "Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's; and unto God the things that are God's," commonly interpreted to remind believers that they also have an obligation to respect temporal authority. In any case, what the Constitution actually says about "freedom of religion" (in the first words of the First Amendment) is this: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof." Seems pretty clear to me.

† As Jesus is reported to have mentioned in Mark 12:31 and Matthew 22:39 as "the second great commandment."

Thursday, May 26, 2016

American Democracy, 2016


Well, at least Texas showed some rare common sense and didn't elect a complete wacko to the State Board of Education. Perhaps there's hope, but I'm not holding my breath ...


Have a good day, and come back tomorrow for more Great Moments in Editing and Signage. More thoughts then.

Bilbo

Tuesday, December 01, 2015

The Things We Choose to Believe


It has been said by people wiser than I that there are subjects one should never discuss. Politics is one. Anything to do with guns (other than worshipful praise) is another. And religion is a third.

As you know, I don't mind discussing politics, although discussing is not always the right word when one's points are often rebutted with ad hominem attacks, non sequiturs, and blind nonsense. Nevertheless, I soldier* on.

As you also know, I have decided no longer to get into the national "debate" on guns, because the rationality train on both sides of the argument sailed a long time ago, and I'm tired of thoughtful discourse being replaced by stupid memes, accusations of my personal stupidity, historical irrelevancies, and arguments of false equivalency. Go ahead and ignore reality if you like, just leave me out of it.

That leaves religion, and depending on how this post is received, it may be the last time I choose to chum those most dangerous of waters.

In the aftermath of the horrific terror attacks by Islamic lunatics in Paris and Bamako, and the murder of several people at a Planned Parenthood clinic in Colorado Springs by a man who was apparently an anti-abortion Christian zealot, the level of hysterical rhetoric has reached levels that surprise even me. Lunatics like Donald Trump advocate building databases to track Muslims, political figures who should know better advocate creating government agencies to advance "Judeo-Christian values"**, and more than half of the nation's governors have demanded that no refugees from Syria or other middle Eastern countries be resettled in their states.

Between the religious crazies of Daesh, Boko Haram, and other radical Islamist groups and the religious crazies of the American Christian far right, it looks like a race to the bottom to see who can espouse the most foul and despicable expressions of religious belief.

With that as an introduction, let me say by way of disclaimer that I am not a religious scholar, nor am I even a "religious" person in the generally accepted sense. I was baptized as a Byzantine Rite Catholic, grew up in a Roman Catholic household, and attended Mass regularly (also serving as a lector) all the way through my college years. As I grew older, traveled more, and saw and experienced more of the world, I gradually fell away from organized religious belief and adopted a more spiritual (for want of a better word) approach. We can discuss the grand philosophical implications of this another time ... what I want to do now is make some comments about the ugly and angry religious fights that make our current world so dangerous. In a series of occasional posts, I want to talk about why I see little difference between the worst Christians and the worst Muslims, beginning with how practitioners of both faiths approach their holy scriptures.

In his great satirical work "The Devil's Dictionary," writer Ambrose Bierce defined Scriptures as, "The sacred books of our holy religion, as distinguished from the false and profane writings on which all other faiths are based." This is about as true as it gets.

For Christians, the Bible is the final, complete, and unerring word of God, true and complete in every detail ... devout Christians spend countless hours in Bible study, seeking deeper understanding of the text.

For Muslims, the Quran is the final, complete and unerring word of God, true and complete in every detail, with every letter of every word exactly as it was passed (in Arabic) from God to Mohammed by way of the angel Gabriel ... many devout Muslims devote themselves to memorizing the entire Quran as an expression of faith.

It seems fairly clear to me that both books can't be the final, revealed word of God ... and who's right depends on whether you are a Christian or a Muslim.

But regardless of how deeply each religion believes in the absolute and complete truth of its scripture, the real truth is that Christians and Muslims must each learn to read and accept those books selectively. The Bible of the New Testament is the story of a loving God of peace and acceptance, whereas the Bible of the Old Testament (see the books of Deuteronomy and Leviticus in particular) specifies some fairly savage punishments for transgressions of The Law*** ... in order to accept Christianity as a religion of love and tolerance, modern Christians learn to believe around these parts of the Bible. Likewise, Muslims - in order to live with their picture of Islam as a religion of peace and tolerance - must read the Quran selectively, ignoring the verses that, for instance, allow men to beat their wives+ and tell believers to fight and subjugate those who follow other faiths++. Few good Christians nowadays kill adulterers or stone their rebellious children to death; likewise, few Muslim men (outside of ultraconservative garden spots like Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Afghanistan) beat their wives or randomly murder their Christian neighbors+++.

Consider the argument about whose religion is one of peace and compassion. Muslims like to point out that the Quran begins with the words, "In the name of God the merciful, the compassionate," and yet some Muslims manage to wreak horrible violence on innocents through selective reading and interpretation of the rest of the text. Christians point out the beauty of the Beatitudes (Matthew 5: 1-12), the peaceful and beautiful story of the Nativity (Luke 2: 1-20), and phrases like "Whatsoever you do to the least of my brothers, you do unto me" (Matthew 25:40), and yet some Christians manage to shoot up abortion clinics, rail against social programs to help the poor, and scream in outrage at the admission of Syrian refugees into this country.

People of good will, mercy, and compassion will find verses in both the Bible and the Quran to which they can point to justify their deepest beliefs. People who wish to use God as a weapon with which to force their beliefs on others can find the same. Belief tends to be selective.

I realize that I am - to use a religious expression - preaching to the converted. If you understand my point, you're probably nodding your head in agreement; if, however, you are a devout believer, you are probably shaking your head in disbelief that I fail to grasp the total, ultimate truth of the (insert your choice of holy scripture here). It's a matter of perspective.

Have a good day. Read your chosen scripture with an eye toward the Golden Rule, and you'll help to make the world a better place†.

More thoughts tomorrow.

Bilbo

* No offense intended to sailors, airmen and Marines.

** I realize that the only part of the Constitution that many Americans care about is the Second Amendment, but we do also have a number of other Amendments, including the very First, which begins with the words, "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof." This seems pretty clear to me, if not to some of the bozoheads running for president.

*** For example: "And the man that committeth adultery with another man's wife, even he that committeth adultery with his neighbour's wife, the adulterer and the adulteress shall surely be put to death" (Leviticus, 20:10); “If a man has a stubborn and rebellious son who will not obey the voice of his father or the voice of his mother, and, though they discipline him, will not listen to them, then his father and his mother shall take hold of him and bring him out to the elders of his city at the gate of the place where he lives, and they shall say to the elders of his city, ‘This our son is stubborn and rebellious; he will not obey our voice; he is a glutton and a drunkard.’ Then all the men of the city shall stone him to death with stones. So you shall purge the evil from your midst, and all Israel shall hear, and fear" (Deuteronomy, 21: 18-21)

+ "Men are the maintainers of women because Allah has made some of them to excel others and because they spend out of their property; the good women are therefore obedient, guarding the unseen as Allah has guarded; and (as to) those on whose part you fear desertion, admonish them, and leave them alone in the sleeping-places and beat them; then if they obey you, do not seek a way against them; surely Allah is High, Great." (Quran, 4:34)

++ "Fight those who do not believe in Allah, nor in the latter day, nor do they prohibit what Allah and His Messenger have prohibited, nor follow the religion of truth, out of those who have been given the Book, until they pay the tax in acknowledgment of superiority and they are in a state of subjection." (Quran, 9:29)

+++ It is a crime in Saudi Arabia to adhere to any religion other than the Wahabi version of Islam, and Pakistan is not noted for its gentle tolerance of other faiths.

† Offer not applicable in much of the Middle East and the American Bible Belt.

Wednesday, September 23, 2015

How to Behave When Company Comes


Tomorrow is the day that Pope Francis is scheduled to speak to a joint session of Congress*. As everyone prepares for the spectacle, some members of Congress, unused to the need to exercise civil and respectful behavior, have asked their - for want of a better term - leadership to provide some guidelines on how to dress and act during the Pope's appearance. This is important because, as one article on the subject put it,

"Francis is famous for making political audiences uncomfortable, and his calls for global leaders to reduce inequality and to act on climate change might sound like an address by President Obama to some Republican lawmakers. At the same time, the pope’s opposition to abortion rights could make some Democrats uncomfortable and lead to GOP cheers, especially given the charged debate over federal funding for Planned Parenthood that’s threatening to trigger a government shutdown** at the end of the month."

If you are surprised that people who are supposed to be grown adults with responsibilities at the national - and, indeed, international - level should need to ask for advice on how to behave, you have clearly not been observing Congressional behavior over the last few years. This is, after all, the body in which a member*** shouted "You lie!" at the President of the United States while he was addressing Congress. One member, Representative Paul Gosnar of Arizona, has already announced that he will boycott the Pope's speech because the Pope might talk about climate change instead of just sticking to religion+.

Nevertheless, our elected reprehensives have promised to be on their best behavior during the Pope's visit, even if they need some adult guidance on how to do it.

Now if we could only find someone to give them some adult guidance on how to behave like responsible men and women doing the people's business, rather than doing their business on the people.

Have a good day. Listen to what the Pope has to say, even if you don't agree with him. It's the respectful thing to do, after all.

More thoughts tomorrow.

Bilbo

* For those of you unfamiliar with this expression, it means that Congress is easier to understand after you've smoked a joint ... or two.

** This is what educated and responsible people might call "government by petulant blackmail."

*** Representative Joe Wilson (R, SC), that paragon of respectful civility.

+ Imagine that ... the man who is supposed to be the representative of God on earth daring to talk about the importance of protecting our common home! As far as we know, God hasn't provided a spare for us to use once we wreck this one.

Wednesday, August 05, 2015

Religious Freedom


This little meme has been making the rounds on Facebook ...


I think it's pretty accurate.

It seems as if nowadays many people's religious beliefs serve less as a guide to an upright and moral personal life than as a cudgel with which to beat those who express a different set of beliefs, or no beliefs at all:

Conservative Christians try to impose on everyone else a muscular Christianity they believe (falsely, as it happens) was written into the Constitution;

Aggressive atheists feel the need to loudly show their disdain for the deeply-felt beliefs of others;

Radical Muslims believe it's their duty to kill those who don't worship as they do;

Some Ultra-Orthodox Jews make life miserable for others by demanding accommodation of their insistence on strict separation of the sexes, to the great embarrassment and inconvenience of everyone else;

And every one of them absolutely, positively believes - beyond all doubt, reason, and compassion - that they, and only they, are right.

Perhaps if we just went back to the Golden Rule, things would be a lot better ... but I think that train sailed long ago.


Have a good day. Live your own life ... the rest of us can take care of our own.

More thoughts tomorrow.

Bilbo

Wednesday, August 27, 2014

Sorry, Wrong Nationality


Rant alert ...

The huge, screaming headline on CNN as I write this is


Well, I hate to burst the bubble of those officials, whoever they are, but anyone fighting for ISIS is not an American. This ass clown made a conscious decision to turn his back on his family and his country and head overseas to fight for a bunch of genocidal religious fanatics who want nothing better than to turn the clock back to an imaginary seventh century paradise. He decided it was more important to be a homicidal religious bigot than a citizen of the greatest nation on earth.

If you think jihad in the service of murderous lunatics like ISIS is your destiny, there are lots of garden spots in the world (Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Afghanistan, to name a few) where you'll be happier than here in the country you spurned. Good riddance.

If it were my decision to make, every one of these fools who leaves the country and fights for some quasi-religious band of thugs should have his passport cancelled immediately. No right of return, no consular protection, no more of the benefits of living in a country that gives him rights no rigidly theocratic regime would ever allow. Enjoy your jihad, but enjoy it somewhere else. You're not coming back.

Mr McCain can hold hell's door open for the rest of his friends. There's plenty of room left for their kind.

Have a good day. Do not refer to these morons as Americans in my hearing.

More thoughts tomorrow, when I calm down.

Bilbo

Tuesday, July 22, 2014

At Least Republicans and Democrats Aren't Killing Each Other*


Warning - political-religious rant. Come back tomorrow for something lighter.

You have been warned.

A while back in this space, I offered a plan for peace in the Middle East that basically involved walling off the entire area, filling it up with sand, and starting over. It was tongue-in-cheek, of course, but - as I pointed out at the time - it was at least as workable as any other plan anyone has offered to bring peace to that tortured part of the world.

Today, as the political crisis and horrifying slaughter continue in Gaza, I have to reluctantly fall back on my plan as the only one that will ever work.

The problem with the Middle East is that it combines the very best of the very worst in human nature: intense and utterly rigid religious beliefs, irreconcilable political demands, and the presence of a resource (oil) that the world needs and wants. Each side has a claim to the same territory, each side believes their claim is just and all others are illegitimate, each side believes God gave that plot of land only to them, and each side believes that it must deal from a position of unquestioned strength in order to prevail. If ever there was a witches' brew of political, historical, and religious hatreds, it's in what we for some reason continue to refer to as the "Holy Land."

The Israelis contend that they are entitled to a homeland in what used to be called Palestine, and cite both religious history and modern politics (such as the Balfour Declaration of 1917 and the 1947 UN resolution partitioning Palestine) as proof of their claim. They point to their sufferings in the Holocaust as a reason why they need a nation that is their own, that they can defend, where they will be safe.

Many Arabs despise the Israelis (Jews) on religious grounds and will never rest in their hatred until the Jews have been driven from the land. Others contend, logically enough, that perhaps the Jews do deserve a homeland as a result of the Holocaust, but that it should be carved out of Europe, where the Holocaust took place, not out of Palestine.

Good luck reconciling all those positions.

The Palestinians don't trust the Israelis. The Israelis don't trust the Palestinians. The Palestinians have earned a reputation for violence that makes much of the world indifferent to their plight, while the Israelis have earned a reputation for intransigence and heavy-handed violence that often undermines their desired image as a plucky little democracy under siege.

Regardless of who you blame for all the historical events that led to today's situation, I absolutely believe the leaders of Hamas bear the ultimate responsibility for the current ongoing carnage. They launched salvos of rockets at Israel in the certain knowledge that the Israelis would retaliate with full force. They chose to launch those rockets from the densely populated Gaza Strip, knowing full well that any Israeli retaliation would kill large numbers of innocent Palestinians. That didn't matter. All that mattered was their hatred of the Israelis. The fact that innocent Gazan Palestinians would be caught in the crossfire was fine with them, because they would be able to show endless photos of devastated neighborhoods and dead children as "proof" that the Israelis were at fault.

I am not an apologist for Israel. I think that the Israelis have brought much of the hatred of the local population on themselves by their actions and policies. But at some point, people on both sides with brains and hearts have to step back and say yes, I may hate you, but enough is enough.

The Palestinians must accept that, however unjust in the beginning and however bitter now, the state of Israel is a reality on the ground. The Israelis will never be rocketed or suicide-bombed into leaving. Such actions will only continue the cycle of violence. They need to stop dreaming of an idyllic past that will not return, and start concentrating on building a future for their children and grandchildren. When Israel withdrew from Gaza, it left behind a territory with an established infrastructure that could have been developed into a thriving center of commerce and tourism. Instead, hard-core Palestinian elements - driven by hatred rather than focused on building for the future - turned it into a constant battleground. Their callous indifference to the well-being of their own people deserves the condemnation of people of good will everywhere.

The Israelis, for their part, must accept that creation of their state resulted in dislocation and hardship for thousands of people who were already living there. They cannot destroy Hamas and the even more extreme groups any more than those groups can destroy the state of Israel. They must stop building settlements in the occupied West Bank, withdraw from that territory as they did from Gaza, and work with the Palestinians to help build a functioning state that can eventually become a partner for development in the region. Given the established hatreds, this will be no easy task, but the alternative is endless repetitions of the same misery and bloodshed.

Regardless of what each side believes, both are at fault.

And the chances of them recognizing it and trying to resolve things peacefully is about nil.


Have a good day. Don't let this happen to us.

More thoughts tomorrow.

Bilbo

* Yet.

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

God's Satisfaction Questionnaire


From my humor collection comes this classic piece ...

God's Satisfaction Questionnaire
Please Answer All Questions

God would like to thank you for your belief and patronage. In order to better serve your needs, He* asks that you take a few moments to answer the following questions. Please keep in mind that your responses will be kept completely confidential, and that you need not disclose your name or address unless you prefer a direct response to comments or suggestions.

1. How did you find out about God?

__ Newspaper
__ Television
__ Word of Mouth
__ Tabloid
__ Bible
__ Torah
__ Other Book (specify): _____________
__ Divine Inspiration
__ Burning Shrubbery
__ Near Death Experience
__ Other (specify): _____________


2. Which model God did you acquire?
__ Yahweh
__ Jehova
__ Allah
__ God
__ Father, Son and Holy Ghost Triplet
__ Jesus
__ Satan
__ None of the above, I was taken in by a false god

3. Did your God come to you undamaged, with all parts in good working order and with no obvious breakage or missing attributes?

__ Yes __ No

If no, please describe the problems you initially encountered. Use a separate sheet of paper if necessary.

4. What factors were relevant in your decision to acquire a god? Please check all that apply.

__ Indoctrinated by Parents
__ Wanted to Piss off Parents
__ Indoctrinated by Society
__ Needed a Reason to Live
__ Needed Focus in Who to Despise
__ Need to Feel Morally Superior to Everyone Else
__ Desperate Need for Certainty
__ Imaginary Friend Grew Up
__ Hate to Think for Myself
__ Needed a Day Away from Work
__ Fear of Death
__ Wanted to Meet Girls/Boys
__ Like Organ Music
__ My shrubbery Caught Fire and Told Me to Do It

5. Have you ever worshipped a God before?
__ Yes __ No

If Yes, which false god were you fooled by? Please check all that apply.

__ Odin
__ Zeus
__ Apollo
__ Ra
__ The Great Spirit
__ The Great Pumpkin
__ The Sun
__ The Moon
__ The Bomb
__ Cthulhu
__ The Almighty Dollar
__ Left Wing Liberalism
__ Right-Wing Conservatism
__ Other: ________________

6. Are you currently using any other source of inspiration in addition to God? Please check all that apply.
__ Tarot
__ Lottery
__ Astrology
__ Television
__ Fortune Cookies
__ Psychic Friends Network
__ Dianetics/Scientology
__ Palmistry
__ Self-Help Books
__ Sex, Drugs and Rock and Roll
__ Biorythms
__ Tea Leaves
__ ESP
__ Chanting Mantras
__ Televangelist (specify which one)
__ Crystals
__ Human Sacrifice
__ Pyramids
__ Wandering around a desert
__ Burning Shrubbery
__ Other: _______________
__ None

7. God employs a limited degree of Divine Intervention to preserve the balanced level of felt presence and blind faith. Which would you prefer (circle one)?

a. More Divine Intervention
b. Less Divine Intervention
c. Current level of Divine Intervention is just right
d. Don't know...what's Divine Intervention?

8. God also attempts to maintain a balanced level of disasters and miracles. Please rate on a scale of 1 - 5 his handling of the following (1=unsatisfactory, 5=excellent):

a. Disasters

Flood 1 2 3 4 5
Pestilence 1 2 3 4 5
War 1 2 3 4 5
Famine 1 2 3 4 5
Plague 1 2 3 4 5
Earthquake 1 2 3 4 5
al Qaeda (or Similar Organization) 1 2 3 4 5
Spam 1 2 3 4 5
Congress 1 2 3 4 5
Tea Party 1 2 3 4 5
Code Pink 1 2 3 4 5

b. Miracles

Rescues 1 2 3 4 5
Water Changing to Wine 1 2 3 4 5
Spontaneous Remissions 1 2 3 4 5
Talking, Flaming Shrubbery 1 2 3 4 5
Stars Hovering over Towns 1 2 3 4 5
Crying Statues 1 2 3 4 5
Cubs Winning the Series 1 2 3 4 5
Congress Actually Does Something Useful 1 2 3 4 5
Walking on Water 1 2 3 4 5
VCRs That Set Their Own Clocks 1 2 3 4 5

9. Do you have any additional comments or suggestions for improving the quality of God's services? (Attach an additional sheet if necessary):

Thank you for your time in completing this valuable survey to help God improve his service to you.

* Please note that God is all-powerful and independent of sex or sexual orientation. The pronouns "He," "His," "Him," etc, are used solely for grammatical convenience and are not intended to specify a particular sex.


Have a good day. Give yourself a plenary indulgence for completing this survey.

More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

Tuesday, May 07, 2013

(Don't) Gimme That Old Time Religion ...


It is said that there are two subjects one should never discuss at dinner (or, indeed, at many other times): politics and religion. This can make it difficult to have a conversation with a far-right Republican, but given the quality of discourse on both sides of the political and religious divide, this may not be a bad thing.

Those of you who have been reading this blog for any length of time know that I am not a conventionally religious person. It's a worldview that I've come to over the decades as I've watched the hideous things done in the name of religion ... in the name of the idea that anyone who doesn't believe this way and no other is automatically bad (at best) or liable to be killed outright (at worst). You can read some of my earlier diatribes here and here if you're so inclined.

Consider this recent event: At Least 27 Dead in Bangladesh Blasphemy Law Rioting. Yes, hysterical mobs in Dakka, Bangladesh, rioted and murdered dozens of people, insisting on the imposition of an anti-blasphemy law that would punish persons who defame Islam with death.

Consider also the disgusting, widely-condemned bigotry of the Westboro Baptist Church, the members of which press their belief in what they believe is the sin of homosexuality by demonstrating at the funerals of people who have nothing at all to do with the subject.

The linkage of deeply fundamentalist religion and violence was explored in this compilation of articles and studies at Religion Link.

Bottom line: to all too many people, religion is not a guiding philosophy or an exhortation to "love one another as I have loved you."* It's an excuse to draw wide red lines between people and whip up hatred of "the other."


So thanks, but don't bother giving me that old-time religion. Especially if you think it empowers you to kill me if I choose not to believe your version of it. With all the problems we have in the world, this is one we just don't need.


Have a good day. Live the Golden Rule. It's all you really need.

More thoughts coming.

Bilbo

* John 15:12.

Wednesday, October 17, 2012

Getting to the Bottom of What's Permissible ... So to Speak


One of the things for which America is justly famous is our freedom of (and from, but that gets lost on the Far Right sometimes) religion. The Founders had recent experience of the religious wars of Europe and didn't want to bring that horror to the new nation they were setting up, and so the Constitution makes it clear (in Article VI) that "no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States," and the Bill of Rights (First Amendment) states that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof."

This is all pretty clear to me, if not to those on the Religious Right who insist that the Founders had a specifically Christian agenda.

But there are other places in the world where the wisdom of avoiding extreme religious belief is not quite as well recognized.

NOTE: the rest of this post is recommended for adults only. You've been warned.

I call your attention to this video clip from the website of the Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI). It features Abdallah al-Khilaf, a London-based Shiite cleric who answers religious questions posted in jihad-focused online discussion groups. In this clip from al-Khilaf's television program in June of this year, he addresses a question posed by a would-be holy warrior who wants to participate in a "martyrdom operation" that involves the use of explosives inserted into the ... um ... nether regions of his body, but is concerned about whether preparation of the appropriate orifice for such an "operation" violates Quranic prohibitions against sodomy.

You will no doubt be pleased to know that the tormented questioner's mind was put at ease by Mr al-Khilaf, who cited a fatwa (religious ruling) by a religious scholar who assured him that, while sodomy was forbidden in principle, it was acceptable when engaged in for purposes of furthering jihad ... although one has to ask God's forgiveness.

Maybe it's just me, but if this is what it takes to get God's attention, I'll just start going back to a church where they still believe in the old love thy neighbor thing, and skip the 72 virgins in paradise.

Have a good day. Worship according to your conscience, but remember that it isn't necessary to kill people who worship according to their own.

Bilbo